Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Two Different Kinds of Teams...and Churches


Back in the day my Atlantic (Iowa) High School basketball team excelled, coming within a whisker of going to State.  After a highly successful year we lost a nail biter to the #1 team in the state, Council Bluffs St. Albert (the eventual state champion).   That loss ended my official basketball career.   While I never starred on my team, over the years I put in the hard work necessary to earn playing time. 

Back in those days we didn’t really have elementary sports, so 7th grade basketball brought at least 25 guys onto the team.   The weeding out process began right away.  Some of the ‘lower end’ players had the joy of playing on the ‘halftime highlights’ team.  While the rest of us took a break and talked to the coach, these guys got to play a ‘game’ that meant nothing to the final score.  The message wasn’t so subtle, “You’re not good enough to be in the REAL game.”  I got stuck in halftime highlights once, but worked my tail off to improve and get off it!  It never happened again.

After that 7th grade year I somehow found myself chosen to be a part of the ‘traveling team’ which went to tournaments all over Iowa.  A couple dads coached the team and had total control over who they chose.  Only 10 of the 25 were on it.   With that team I spent many hours honing my skills and winning tournaments.  

It came as little surprise over the next years that those of us who played the most off-season games and shot the most baskets got the most playing time during the season.  Many people saw the writing on the wall and dropped out of the program.  Others had to be bluntly told, “You’re not going to play on this team.”  By the time our senior year rolled around only a few of us remained.   Our success reflected our dedication to the sport.  We didn’t need a big team…we needed the dedicated people on the team.  It nearly got us to state!  Success mattered!

Back in the day my Atlantic (Iowa) High School cross country team had a little success.  Our varsity boys tended to finish in the middle of the pack…but I never ran with the varsity.  I spent my junior and senior years on the JV squad (as part of the off season training for Mr. Blazek, my basketball coach).  Even though I’d never been in a race before, the cross country team welcomed me with open arms.  Anyone crazy enough to run 3.1 miles could join the team, no experience (or training) necessary.  While some of my teammates spent the summer running countless miles, I did almost no running at all (unless there was a cute girl who wanted to run with me!).   I showed up to the first practices of the year completely out of shape, but people encouraged me as I huffed and puffed my way through practices.   When race day came I usually finished somewhere in the back half of the JV race.  I had no illusions of grandeur but I really enjoyed being a part of the team.  We had a load of fun…the team abounded in quirky people!  Cross country teams have room for many.  There isn’t limited playing time since any number can run in JV races, so the more the merrier!  Mr. Henderson and my teammates encouraged me to be on the team and do my best, even though my best was frankly pretty bad.  All were welcome…no experience necessary.

Two very different ideas of what it means to be a team!  One team had high demands and weeded out those not willing to put in the time.  One team had low demands and welcomed everyone.  They each have their place.

I’ve known churches on both ends of the same spectrum.

Like my basketball team, some churches place high demands on their members.   They emphasize the Jesus who asked people to ‘take up their cross and follow Him.’  Jesus is serious about us…so we should be serious about Jesus.  They hold up the marks of discipleship (things like worship, prayer, study, acts of mercy & service) as definite expectations of their members.  Jesus isn’t something to dabble in!  Those who aren’t willing to make the commitment are welcome to be a part of the ministry…just not as full members.   The expectation is that eventually they will step up to the plate.  Dedication to the faith is central.  I’ve seen some of these churches grow significantly, though some people feel pushed away for not being ‘good enough’ to be a part of things.  Do seemingly arbitrary rules trump grace in the desire for a ‘pure’ worshipping community.

Like my cross country team, some churches place very low demands on their members.  They emphasize the Jesus who came to welcome all people.  Come as you are because grace abounds.  Once a part of the ministry folks are encouraged to grow in faith, but welcoming trumps all.  Too many expectations may drive people away so they are kept to a minimum.  The Christian life is offered as an invitation, not a demand.  I’ve seen some of these churches grow significantly, especially among those who have been pushed away from other communities of faith, but do they minimize the importance of Jesus in our lives in the desire to welcome all?

Our culture likes to push at the extremes (and argue about them), but might there be middle ground here?  How can a community of faith truly welcome all as Jesus did…yet also expect that people of faith have some accountability in their lives?  Let’s not fall off the cliff on either end!

No comments:

Post a Comment